2 h 2 min
Refuting the unfolding-argument on the irrelevance of causal structure to consciousness
Consciousness, Philosophy of Mind, Cognition and seminar by Marius Usher, Tel-Aviv University
Hosted by Asia Pacific Consciousness Network
Thursday 15:00–16:30 Melbourne (GMT+11)
Recording available
Recording
Abstract
I will build from Niccolo's discussion of the Blockhead argument to argue that having an FeedForward Network (FN) responding like an recurrent network (RN) in a consciousness experiment is not enough to convince us the two are the same with regards to the posession of mental states and conscious experience. I will then argue that a robust functional equivalence between FFN and RN is akso not supported by the mathematical work on the Universal Approximator theorem, and is also unlikely to hold, as a conjecture, given data in cognitive neuroscience; I will argue that an equivalence of RN and FFN may only apply to static functions between input/output layers and not to the temporal patterns or to the network's reactions to structural perturbations. Finally, I review data indicating that consciousness has functional characteristics, such as a flexible control of behavior, and that cognitive/brain dynamics reveal interacting top-down and bottom-up processes, which are necessary for the mediation of such control processes.
Topics
Related seminars
On the link between conscious function and general intelligence in humans and machines
Video · 56 min · Nov 18, 2022Arthur Juliani, Microsoft ResearchIntegration and unification in the science of consciousness
Video · 51 min · Jan 30, 2021Wanja Wiese, Johannes Gutenberg University of MainzIrruption theory of consciousness
Video · 1 h 35 min · Aug 18, 2021Tom Froese, Okinawa Institute of Science and Technology Graduate University
More from Asia Pacific Consciousness Network
All talksConsciousness and implicit learning
Video · 1 h 33 min · Dec 13, 2021Qiufang FuRoles of attention and consciousness in perceptual learning
Video · 1 h 33 min · Dec 13, 2021Kazuhisa ShibataThe Unfolding Argument: theoretical and methodological implications
Video · 2 h 2 min · Dec 2, 2021Niccolo NegroData spaces: category (sheaf) theory and phenomenology
Video · 1 h 43 min · Nov 16, 2021Steven Phillips