Stability and Bifurcations in a Free Boundary PDE Models of Cell Motility
Leonid Berlyand discusses mathematical models for the onset of cell motion driven by myosin contraction. A two-dimensional free-boundary PDE model links cell-shape evolution to diffusion and Keller–Segel-type transport. The talk examines linear stability, a stability-determining eigenvalue and the way nonlinear diffusion changes the bifurcation from supercritical to subcritical. It also considers the curvature of the bifurcation curve, connections to bistability, and the role of non-self-adjoint operators. An example illustrates why a spectral gap alone need not guarantee stability. This is an in-person Analysis of Fluids and Related Topics seminar at Princeton.
Towards model-based control of active matter: active nematics and oscillator networks
The richness of active matter's spatiotemporal patterns continues to capture our imagination. Shaping these emergent dynamics into pre-determined forms of our choosing is a grand challenge in the field. To complicate matters, multiple dynamical attractors can coexist in such systems, leading to initial condition-dependent dynamics. Consequently, non-trivial spatiotemporal inputs are generally needed to access these states. Optimal control theory provides a general framework for identifying such inputs and represents a promising computational tool for guiding experiments and interacting with various systems in soft active matter and biology. As an exemplar, I first consider an extensile active nematic fluid confined to a disk. In the absence of control, the system produces two topological defects that perpetually circulate. Optimal control identifies a time-varying active stress field that restructures the director field, flipping the system to its other attractor that rotates in the opposite direction. As a second, analogous case, I examine a small network of coupled Belousov-Zhabotinsky chemical oscillators that possesses two dominant attractors, two wave states of opposing chirality. Optimal control similarly achieves the task of attractor switching. I conclude with a few forward-looking remarks on how the same model-based control approach might come to bear on problems in biology.
Metachronal waves in swarms of nematode Turbatrix aceti
There is a recent surge of interest in the behavior of active particles that can at the same time align their direction of movement and synchronize their oscillations, known as swarmalators. While analytical and numerical models of such systems are now abundant, no real-life examples have been shown to date. I will present an experimental investigation of the collective motion of the nematode Turbatrix aceti, which self-propel by body undulation. I will show that under favorable conditions these nematodes can synchronize their body oscillations, forming striking traveling metachronal waves which, similar to the case of beating cilia, produce strong fluid flows. I will demonstrate that the location and strength of this collective state can be controlled through the shape of the confining structure; in our case the contact angle of a droplet. This opens a way for producing controlled work such as on-demand flows or displacement of objects. I will illustrate this by a practical example: showing that the force generated by the collectively moving nematodes is sufficient to change the mode of evaporation of fluid droplets, by counteracting the surface-tension force, which allow us to estimate its strength.
Growing in flows: from evolutionary dynamics to microbial jets
Biological systems can self-organize in complex structures, able to evolve and adapt to widely varying environmental conditions. Despite the importance of fluid flow for transporting and organizing populations, few laboratory systems exist to systematically investigate the impact of advection on their spatial evolutionary dynamics. In this talk, I will discuss how we can address this problem by studying the morphology and genetic spatial structure of microbial colonies growing on the surface of a viscous substrate. When grown on a liquid, I will show that S. cerevisiae (baker’s yeast) can behave like “active matter” and collectively generate a fluid flow many times larger than the unperturbed colony expansion speed, which in turn produces mechanical stresses and fragmentation of the initial colony. Combining laboratory experiments with numerical modeling, I will demonstrate that the coupling between metabolic activity and hydrodynamic flows can produce positive feedbacks and drive preferential growth phenomena leading to the formation of microbial jets. Our work provides rich opportunities to explore the interplay between hydrodynamics, growth and competition within a versatile system.
Internal structure of honey bee swarms for mechanical stability and division of labor
The western honey bee (Apis mellifera) is a domesticated pollinator famous for living in highly social colonies. In the spring, thousands of worker bees and a queen fly from their hive in search of a new home. They self-assemble into a swarm that hangs from a tree branch for several days. We reconstruct the non-isotropic arrangement of worker bees inside swarms made up of 3000 - 8000 bees using x-ray computed tomography. Some bees are stationary and hang from the attachment board or link their bodies into hanging chains to support the swarm structure. The remaining bees use the chains as pathways to walk around the swarm, potentially to feed the queen or communicate with one another. The top layers of bees bear more weight per bee than the remainder of the swarm, suggesting that bees are optimizing for additional factors besides weight distribution. Despite not having a clear leader, honey bees are able to organize into a swarm that protects the queen and remains stable until scout bees locate a new hive.
Trapping active particles up to the limiting case: bacteria enclosed in a biofilm
Active matter systems are composed of constituents, each one in nonequilibrium, that consume energy in order to move [1]. A characteristic feature of active matter is collective motion leading to nonequilibrium phase transitions or large scale directed motion [2]. A number of recent works have featured active particles interacting with obstacles, either moving or fixed [3,4,5]. When an active particle encounters an asymmetric obstacle, different behaviours are detected depending on the nature of its active motion. On the one side, rectification effects arise in a suspension of run-and-tumble particles interacting with a wall of funnelled-shaped openings, caused by particles persistence length [6]. The same trapping mechanism could be responsible for the intake of microorganisms in the underground leaves [7] of Carnivorous plants [8]. On the other side, for aligning particles [9] interacting with a wall of funnelled-shaped openings, trapping happens on the (opposite) wider opening side of the funnels [10,11]. Interestingly, when funnels are located on a circular array, trapping is more localised and depends on the nature of the Vicsek model. Active particles can be synthetic (such as synthetic active colloids) or alive (such as living bacteria). A prototypical model to study living microswimmers is P. fluorescens, a rod shaped and biofilm forming bacterium. Biofilms are microbial communities self-assembled onto external interfaces. Biofilms can be described within the Soft Matter physics framework [12] as a viscoelastic material consisting of colloids (bacterial cells) embedded in a cross-linked polymer gel (polysaccharides cross-linked via proteins/multivalent cations), whose water content vary depending on the environmental conditions. Bacteria embedded in the polymeric matrix control biofilm structure and mechanical properties by regulating its matrix composition. We have recently monitored structural features of Pseudomonas fluorescens biofilms grown with and without hydrodynamic stress [13,14]. We have demonstrated that bacteria are capable of self-adapting to hostile hydrodynamic stress by tailoring the biofilm chemical composition, thus affecting both the mesoscale structure of the matrix and its viscoelastic properties that ultimately regulate the bacteria-polymer interactions. REFERENCES [1] C. Bechinger et al. Rev. Mod. Phys. 88, 045006 (2016); [2] T. Vicsek, A. Zafeiris Phys. Rep. 517, 71 (2012); [3] C. Bechinger, R. Di Leonardo, H. Lowen, C. Reichhardt, G. Volpe, and G. Volpe, Reviews of Modern Physics 88, 045006 (2016); [4] R Martinez, F Alarcon, DR Rodriguez, JL Aragones, C Valeriani The European Physical Journal E 41, 1 (2018); [5] DR Rodriguez, F Alarcon, R Martinez, J Ramírez, C Valeriani, Soft matter 16 (5), 1162 (2020); [6] C. O. Reichhardt and C. Reichhardt, Annual Review of Condensed Matter Physics 8, 51 (2017); [7] W Barthlott, S Porembski, E Fischer, B Gemmel Nature 392, 447 (1998); [8] C B. Giuliano, R Zhang, R.Martinez Fernandez, C.Valeriani and L.Wilson (in preparation, 2021); [9] R Martinez, F Alarcon, JL Aragones, C Valeriani Soft matter 16 (20), 4739 (2020); [10] P. Galajada, J. Keymer, P. Chaikin and R.Austin, Journal of bacteriology, 189, 8704 (2007); [11] M. Wan, C.O. Reichhardt, Z. Nussinov, and C. Reichhardt, Physical Review Letters 101, 018102 (2008); [12] J N. Wilking , T E. Angelini , A Seminara , M P. Brenner , and D A. Weitz MRS Bulletin 36, 385 (2011); [13]J Jara, F Alarcón, A K Monnappa, J Ignacio Santos, V Bianco, P Nie, M Pica Ciamarra, A Canales, L Dinis, I López-Montero, C Valeriani, B Orgaz, Frontiers in microbiology 11, 3460 (2021); [14] P Nie, F Alarcon, I López-Montero, B Orgaz, C Valeriani, M Pica Ciamarra
Liquid-liquid phase separation out of equilibrium
Living cells contain millions of enzymes and proteins, which carry out multiple reactions simultaneously. To optimize these processes, cells compartmentalize reactions in membraneless liquid condensates. Certain features of cellular condensates can be explained by principles of liquid-liquid phase separation studied in material science. However, biological condensates exist in the inherently out of equilibrium environment of a living cell, being driven by force-generating microscopic processes. These cellular conditions are fundamentally different than the equilibrium conditions of liquid-liquid phase separation studied in materials science and physics. How condensates function in the active riotous environment of a cell is essential for understanding of cellular functions, as well as to the onset of neurodegenerative diseases. Currently, we lack model systems that enable rigorous studies of these processes. Living cells are too complex for quantitative analysis, while reconstituted equilibrium condensates fail to capture the non-equilibrium environment of biological cells. To bridge this gap, we reconstituted a DNA based membraneless condensates in an active environment that mimics the conditions of a living cell. We combine condensates with a reconstituted network of cytoskeletal filaments and molecular motors, and study how the mechanical interactions change the phase behavior and dynamics of membraneless structures. Studying these composite materials elucidates the fundamental physics rules that govern the behavior of liquid-liquid phase separation away from equilibrium while providing insight into the mechanism of condensate phase separation in cellular environments.
Mixed active-passive suspensions: from particle entrainment to spontaneous demixing
Understanding the properties of active matter is a challenge which is currently driving a rapid growth in soft- and bio-physics. Some of the most important examples of active matter are at the microscale, and include active colloids and suspensions of microorganisms, both as a simple active fluid (single species) and as mixed suspensions of active and passive elements. In this last class of systems, recent experimental and theoretical work has started to provide a window into new phenomena including activity-induced depletion interactions, phase separation, and the possibility to extract net work from active suspensions. Here I will present our work on a paradigmatic example of mixed active-passive system, where the activity is provided by swimming microalgae. Macro- and micro-scopic experiments reveal that microorganism-colloid interactions are dominated by rare close encounters leading to large displacements through direct entrainment. Simulations and theoretical modelling show that the ensuing particle dynamics can be understood in terms of a simple jump-diffusion process, combining standard diffusion with Poisson-distributed jumps. Entrainment length can be understood within the framework of Taylor dispersion as a competition between advection by the no-slip surface of the cell body and microparticle diffusion. Building on these results, we then ask how external control of the dynamics of the active component (e.g. induced microswimmer anisotropy/inhomogeneity) can be used to alter the transport of passive cargo. As a first step in this direction, we study the behaviour of mixed active-passive systems in confinement. The resulting spatial inhomogeneity in swimmers’ distribution and orientation has a dramatic effect on the spatial distribution of passive particles, with the colloids accumulating either towards the boundaries or towards the bulk of the sample depending on the size of the container. We show that this can be used to induce the system to de-mix spontaneously.
TBD
Imposed flow in active liquid crystals
Inspired by ongoing experiments on three dimensional active gels composed of sliding microtubule bundles, we study a few idealized problems in a minimal hydrodynamic model for active liquid crystals. Our aim is to use flow to determine the value of the coefficient of activity in a continuum theory. We consider the case of apolar active particles that form a disordered phase in the absence of flow, and study how activity affects the swimming speed of a prescribed swimmer, as well as the stability of a fluid interface. We also consider flows of active matter in channels or past immersed objects.
Physics in Life and Medicine
Spontaneous and driven active matter flows
Understanding individual and macroscopic transport properties of motile micro-organisms in complex environments is a timely question, relevant to many ecological, medical and technological situations. At the fundamental level, this question is also receiving a lot of attention as fluids loaded with swimming micro-organisms has become a rich domain of applications and a conceptual playground for the statistical physics of “active matter”. The existence of microscopic sources of energy borne by the motile character of these micro-swimmers is driving self-organization processes at the origin of original emergent phases and unconventional macroscopic properties leading to revisit many standard concepts in the physics of suspensions. In this presentation, I will report on a recent exploration on the question of spontaneous formation of large scale collective motion in relation with the rheological response of active suspensions. I will also present new experiments showing how the motility of bacteria can be controlled such as to extract work macroscopically.
(What) can soft matter physics teach us about biological function?
The “soft, active, and living matter” community has grown tremendously in recent years, conducting exciting research at the interface between soft matter and biological systems. But are all living systems also soft matter systems? Do the ideas of function (or purpose) in biological systems require us to introduce deep new ideas into the framework of soft matter theories? Does the (often) qualitatively different character of data in biological experiments require us to change the types of experiments we conduct and the goals of our theoretical treatments? Eight speakers will anchor the workshop, exploring these questions across a range of biological system scales. Each speaker will deliver a 10-minute talk with another 10 minutes set aside for moderated questions/discussion. We expect the talks to be broad, bold, and provocative, discussing both the nature of the theoretical tools and experimental techniques we have at present and also those we think we will ultimately need to answer deep questions at the interface of soft matter and biology.