experiment
Latest
Odd dynamics of living chiral crystals
The emergent dynamics exhibited by collections of living organisms often shows signatures of symmetries that are broken at the single-organism level. At the same time, organism development itself encompasses a well-coordinated sequence of symmetry breaking events that successively transform a single, nearly isotropic cell into an animal with well-defined body axis and various anatomical asymmetries. Combining these key aspects of collective phenomena and embryonic development, we describe here the spontaneous formation of hydrodynamically stabilized active crystals made of hundreds of starfish embryos that gather during early development near fluid surfaces. We describe a minimal hydrodynamic theory that is fully parameterized by experimental measurements of microscopic interactions among embryos. Using this theory, we can quantitatively describe the stability, formation and rotation of crystals and rationalize the emergence of mechanical properties that carry signatures of an odd elastic material. Our work thereby quantitatively connects developmental symmetry breaking events on the single-embryo level with remarkable macroscopic material properties of a novel living chiral crystal system.
Magnetic Handshake Materials
Biological materials gain complexity from the programmable nature of their components. To manufacture materials with comparable complexity synthetically, we need to create building blocks with low crosstalk so that they only bind to their desired partners. Canonically, these building blocks are made using DNA strands or proteins to achieve specificity. Here we propose a new materials platform, termed Magnetic Handshake Materials, in which we program interactions through designing magnetic dipole patterns. This is a completely synthetic platform, enabled by magnetic printing technology, which is easier to both model theoretically and control experimentally. In this seminar, I will give an overview of the development of the Magnetic Handshake Materials platform, ranging from interaction, assembly to function design.
Emergence of homochirality in large molecular systems
The question of the origin of homochirality of living matter, or the dominance of one handedness for all molecules of life across the entire biosphere, is a long-standing puzzle in the research on the Origin of Life. In the fifties, Frank proposed a mechanism to explain homochirality based on the properties of a simple autocatalytic network containing only a few chemical species. Following this work, chemists struggled to find experimental realizations of this model, possibly due to a lack of proper methods to identify autocatalysis [1]. In any case, a model based on a few chemical species seems rather limited, because prebiotic earth is likely to have consisted of complex ‘soups’ of chemicals. To include this aspect of the problem, we recently proposed a mechanism based on certain features of large out-of-equilibrium chemical networks [2]. We showed that a phase transition towards an homochiral state is likely to occur as the number of chiral species in the system becomes large or as the amount of free energy injected into the system increases. Through an analysis of large chemical databases, we showed that there is no need for very large molecules for chiral species to dominate over achiral ones; it already happens when molecules contain about 10 heavy atoms. We also analyzed the various conventions used to measure chirality and discussed the relative chiral signs adopted by different groups of molecules [3]. We then proposed a generalization of Frank’s model for large chemical networks, which we characterized using random matrix theory. This analysis includes sparse networks, suggesting that the emergence of homochirality is a robust and generic transition. References: [1] A. Blokhuis, D. Lacoste, and P. Nghe, PNAS (2020), 117, 25230. [2] G. Laurent, D. Lacoste, and P. Gaspard, PNAS (2021) 118 (3) e2012741118. [3] G. Laurent, D. Lacoste, and P. Gaspard, Proc. R. Soc. A 478:20210590 (2022).
4D Chromosome Organization: Combining Polymer Physics, Knot Theory and High Performance Computing
Self-organization is a universal concept spanning numerous disciplines including mathematics, physics and biology. Chromosomes are self-organizing polymers that fold into orderly, hierarchical and yet dynamic structures. In the past decade, advances in experimental biology have provided a means to reveal information about chromosome connectivity, allowing us to directly use this information from experiments to generate 3D models of individual genes, chromosomes and even genomes. In this talk I will present a novel data-driven modeling approach and discuss a number of possibilities that this method holds. I will discuss a detailed study of the time-evolution of X chromosome inactivation, highlighting both global and local properties of chromosomes that result in topology-driven dynamical arrest and present and characterize a novel type of motion we discovered in knots that may have applications to nanoscale materials and machines.
Towards model-based control of active matter: active nematics and oscillator networks
The richness of active matter's spatiotemporal patterns continues to capture our imagination. Shaping these emergent dynamics into pre-determined forms of our choosing is a grand challenge in the field. To complicate matters, multiple dynamical attractors can coexist in such systems, leading to initial condition-dependent dynamics. Consequently, non-trivial spatiotemporal inputs are generally needed to access these states. Optimal control theory provides a general framework for identifying such inputs and represents a promising computational tool for guiding experiments and interacting with various systems in soft active matter and biology. As an exemplar, I first consider an extensile active nematic fluid confined to a disk. In the absence of control, the system produces two topological defects that perpetually circulate. Optimal control identifies a time-varying active stress field that restructures the director field, flipping the system to its other attractor that rotates in the opposite direction. As a second, analogous case, I examine a small network of coupled Belousov-Zhabotinsky chemical oscillators that possesses two dominant attractors, two wave states of opposing chirality. Optimal control similarly achieves the task of attractor switching. I conclude with a few forward-looking remarks on how the same model-based control approach might come to bear on problems in biology.
Towards a Theory of Microbial Ecosystems
A major unresolved question in microbiome research is whether the complex ecological patterns observed in surveys of natural communities can be explained and predicted by fundamental, quantitative principles. Bridging theory and experiment is hampered by the multiplicity of ecological processes that simultaneously affect community assembly and a lack of theoretical tools for modeling diverse ecosystems. Here, I will present a simple ecological model of microbial communities that reproduces large-scale ecological patterns observed across multiple natural and experimental settings including compositional gradients, clustering by environment, diversity/harshness correlations, and nestedness. Surprisingly, our model works despite having a “random metabolisms” and “random consumer preferences”. This raises the natural of question of why random ecosystems can describe real-world experimental data. In the second, more theoretical part of the talk, I will answer this question by showing that when a community becomes diverse enough, it will always self-organize into a stable state whose properties are well captured by a “typical random ecosystems”.
Reconstruct cellular dynamics from single cell data
Recent advances of single cell techniques catalyzed quantitative studies on the dynamics of cell phenotypic transitions (CPT) emerging as a new field. However, fixed cell-based approaches have fundamental limits on revealing temporal information, and fluorescence-based live cell imaging approaches are technically challenging for multiplex long-term imaging. To tackle the challenges, we developed an integrated experimental/computational platform for reconstructing single cell phenotypic transition dynamics. Experimentally, we developed a live-cell imaging platform to record the phenotypic transition path of A549 VIM-RFP reporter cell line and unveil parallel paths of epithelial-to-mesenchymal transition (EMT). Computationally, we modified a finite temperature string method to reconstruct the reaction coordinate from the paths, and reconstruct a corresponding quasi-potential, which reveals that the EMT process resembles a barrier-less relaxation process. Our work demonstrates the necessity of extracting dynamical information of phenotypic transitions and the existence of a unified theoretical framework describing transition and relaxation dynamics in systems with and without detailed balance.
Mechano-adaptation in a large protein complex
Macromolecular protein complexes perform essential biological functions across life forms. A fundamental, though yet unsolved question in biology is how the function of such complexes is regulated by intracellular or extracellular signals. For instance, we have little understanding of how forces affect multi-protein machines whose function is often mechanical in nature. We address this question by studying the bacterial flagellar motor, a large complex that powers swimming motility in many bacteria. This rotary motor autonomously adapts to changes in mechanical load by adding or removing force-generating ‘stator’ units that power rotation. In the bacterium Escherichia coli, up to 11 units drive the motor at high load while all the units are released at low load. We manipulate motor load using electrorotation, a technique in which a rapidly rotating electric field applies an external torque on the motor. This allows us to change motor load at will and measure the resulting stator dynamics at single-unit resolution. We found that the force generated by the stator units controls their unbinding, forming a feedback loop that leads to autoregulation of the assembly. We complemented our experiments with theoretical models that provide insight into the underlying molecular interactions. Torque-dependent remodeling takes place within seconds, making it a highly responsive control mechanism, one that is mediated by the mechano-chemical tuning of protein interactions.
Metachronal waves in swarms of nematode Turbatrix aceti
There is a recent surge of interest in the behavior of active particles that can at the same time align their direction of movement and synchronize their oscillations, known as swarmalators. While analytical and numerical models of such systems are now abundant, no real-life examples have been shown to date. I will present an experimental investigation of the collective motion of the nematode Turbatrix aceti, which self-propel by body undulation. I will show that under favorable conditions these nematodes can synchronize their body oscillations, forming striking traveling metachronal waves which, similar to the case of beating cilia, produce strong fluid flows. I will demonstrate that the location and strength of this collective state can be controlled through the shape of the confining structure; in our case the contact angle of a droplet. This opens a way for producing controlled work such as on-demand flows or displacement of objects. I will illustrate this by a practical example: showing that the force generated by the collectively moving nematodes is sufficient to change the mode of evaporation of fluid droplets, by counteracting the surface-tension force, which allow us to estimate its strength.
Growing in flows: from evolutionary dynamics to microbial jets
Biological systems can self-organize in complex structures, able to evolve and adapt to widely varying environmental conditions. Despite the importance of fluid flow for transporting and organizing populations, few laboratory systems exist to systematically investigate the impact of advection on their spatial evolutionary dynamics. In this talk, I will discuss how we can address this problem by studying the morphology and genetic spatial structure of microbial colonies growing on the surface of a viscous substrate. When grown on a liquid, I will show that S. cerevisiae (baker’s yeast) can behave like “active matter” and collectively generate a fluid flow many times larger than the unperturbed colony expansion speed, which in turn produces mechanical stresses and fragmentation of the initial colony. Combining laboratory experiments with numerical modeling, I will demonstrate that the coupling between metabolic activity and hydrodynamic flows can produce positive feedbacks and drive preferential growth phenomena leading to the formation of microbial jets. Our work provides rich opportunities to explore the interplay between hydrodynamics, growth and competition within a versatile system.
How polymer-loop-extruding motors shape chromosomes
Chromosomes are extremely long, active polymers that are spatially organized across multiple scales to promote cellular functions, such as gene transcription and genetic inheritance. During each cell cycle, chromosomes are dramatically compacted as cells divide and dynamically reorganized into less compact, spatiotemporally patterned structures after cell division. These activities are facilitated by DNA/chromatin-binding protein motors called SMC complexes. Each of these motors can perform a unique activity known as “loop extrusion,” in which the motor binds the DNA/chromatin polymer, reels in the polymer fiber, and extrudes it as a loop. Using simulations and theory, I show how loop-extruding motors can collectively compact and spatially organize chromosomes in different scenarios. First, I show that loop-extruding complexes can generate sufficient compaction for cell division, provided that loop-extrusion satisfies stringent physical requirements. Second, while loop-extrusion alone does not uniquely spatially pattern the genome, interactions between SMC complexes and protein “boundary elements” can generate patterns that emerge in the genome after cell division. Intriguingly, these “boundary elements” are not necessarily stationary, which can generate a variety of patterns in the neighborhood of transcriptionally active genes. These predictions, along with supporting experiments, show how SMC complexes and other molecular machinery, such as RNA polymerase, can spatially organize the genome. More generally, this work demonstrates both the versatility of the loop extrusion mechanism for chromosome functional organization and how seemingly subtle microscopic effects can emerge in the spatiotemporal structure of nonequilibrium polymers.
Internal structure of honey bee swarms for mechanical stability and division of labor
The western honey bee (Apis mellifera) is a domesticated pollinator famous for living in highly social colonies. In the spring, thousands of worker bees and a queen fly from their hive in search of a new home. They self-assemble into a swarm that hangs from a tree branch for several days. We reconstruct the non-isotropic arrangement of worker bees inside swarms made up of 3000 - 8000 bees using x-ray computed tomography. Some bees are stationary and hang from the attachment board or link their bodies into hanging chains to support the swarm structure. The remaining bees use the chains as pathways to walk around the swarm, potentially to feed the queen or communicate with one another. The top layers of bees bear more weight per bee than the remainder of the swarm, suggesting that bees are optimizing for additional factors besides weight distribution. Despite not having a clear leader, honey bees are able to organize into a swarm that protects the queen and remains stable until scout bees locate a new hive.
Bacterial rheotaxis in bulk and at surfaces
Individual bacteria transported in viscous flows, show complex interactions with flows and bounding surfaces resulting from their complex shape as well as their activity. Understanding these transport dynamics is crucial, as they impact soil contamination, transport in biological conducts or catheters, and constitute thus a serious health threat. Here we investigate the trajectories of individual E-coli bacteria in confined geometries under flow, using microfluidic model systems in bulk flows as well as close to surfaces using a novel Langrangian 3D tracking method. Combining experimental observations and modelling we elucidate the origin of upstream swimming, lateral drift or persistent transport along corners. [1] Junot et al, EPL, 126 (2019) 44003 [2] Mathijssen et al. 10:3 (2019) Nature Comm. [3] Figueroa-Morales et al., Soft Matter, 2015,11, 6284-6293 [4] Darnige et al. Review of Scientific Instruments 88, 055106 (2017) [5] Jing et al, Science Advances, 2020; 6 : eabb2012 [6] Figueroa-Morales et al, Sci. Adv. 2020; 6 : eaay0155, 2020, 10.1126/sciadv.aay0155
Flocking through complex environments
The spontaneous collective motion of self-propelled agents is ubiquitous in the natural world, and it often occurs in complex environments, be it bacteria and cells migrating through polymeric extracellular matrix or animal herds and human crowds navigating structured terrains. Much is known about flocking dynamics in pristine backgrounds, but how do spatio-temporal heterogeneities in the environment impact such collective self-organization? I will present two model systems, a colloidal active fluid negotiating disordered obstacles and a confined dense bacterial suspension in a viscoelastic medium, as controllable platforms to explore this question and highlight general mechanisms for active self-organization in complex environments. By combining theory and experiment, I will show how flocks on disordered substrates organize into a novel dynamic vortex glass phase, akin to vortex glasses in dirty superconductors, while the presence of viscoelasticity can calm the otherwise turbulent swarming of bacteria, allowing the emergence of a large scale coherent and even oscillatory vortex when confined on the millimetre scale.
Energy landscapes, order and disorder, and protein sequence coevolution: From proteins to chromosome structure
In vivo, the human genome folds into a characteristic ensemble of 3D structures. The mechanism driving the folding process remains unknown. A theoretical model for chromatin (the minimal chromatin model) explains the folding of interphase chromosomes and generates chromosome conformations consistent with experimental data is presented. The energy landscape of the model was derived by using the maximum entropy principle and relies on two experimentally derived inputs: a classification of loci into chromatin types and a catalog of the positions of chromatin loops. This model was generalized by utilizing a neural network to infer these chromatin types using epigenetic marks present at a locus, as assayed by ChIP-Seq. The ensemble of structures resulting from these simulations completely agree with HI-C data and exhibits unknotted chromosomes, phase separation of chromatin types, and a tendency for open chromatin to lie at the periphery of chromosome territories. Although this theoretical methodology was trained in one cell line, the human GM12878 lymphoblastoid cells, it has successfully predicted the structural ensembles of multiple human cell lines. Finally, going beyond Hi-C, our predicted structures are also consistent with microscopy measurements. Analysis of both structures from simulation and microscopy reveals that short segments of chromatin make two-state transitions between closed conformations and open dumbbell conformations. For gene active segments, the vast majority of genes appear clustered in the linker region of the chromatin segment, allowing us to speculate possible mechanisms by which chromatin structure and dynamics may be involved in controlling gene expression. * Supported by the NSF
Microorganism locomotion in viscoelastic fluids
Many microorganisms and cells function in complex (non-Newtonian) fluids, which are mixtures of different materials and exhibit both viscous and elastic stresses. For example, mammalian sperm swim through cervical mucus on their journey through the female reproductive tract, and they must penetrate the viscoelastic gel outside the ovum to fertilize. In micro-scale swimming the dynamics emerge from the coupled interactions between the complex rheology of the surrounding media and the passive and active body dynamics of the swimmer. We use computational models of swimmers in viscoelastic fluids to investigate and provide mechanistic explanations for emergent swimming behaviors. I will discuss how flexible filaments (such as flagella) can store energy from a viscoelastic fluid to gain stroke boosts due to fluid elasticity. I will also describe 3D simulations of model organisms such as C. Reinhardtii and mammalian sperm, where we use experimentally measured stroke data to separate naturally coupled stroke and fluid effects. We explore why strokes that are adapted to Newtonian fluid environments might not do well in viscoelastic environments.
Flocks and crowds: a Gulliver travel
In the first part of my talk, combining experimental, numerical and theoretical results, I will explain how self-propelled colloidal particles self-organize in one of the most robust ordered state found in nature: flocks. I will explain how to describe macroscopic flocking motion as the spontaneous flows of an active fluid, and use this framework to elucidate the phase ordering dynamics of polar active matter. In the second part of my talk, I will show that the same tools and concepts can be effectively used to infer a hydrodynamic description of active fluids composed of particles 6 order of magnitude larger in size: pedestrian crowds.
Sperm have got the bends
The journey of development begins with sperm swimming through the female reproductive tract en-route to the egg. In order to successfully complete this journey sperm must beat a single flagellum, propelling themselves through a wide range of fluids, from liquified semen to viscous cervical mucus. It is well-known that the beating tail is driven by an array of 9 microtubule doublets surrounding a central pair, with interconnecting dynein motors generating shear forces and driving elastic wave propagation. Despite this knowledge, the exact mechanism by which coordination of these motors drives oscillating waves along the flagellum remains unknown; hypothesised mechanisms include curvature control, sliding control, and geometric clutch. In this talk we will discuss the mechanisms of flagellar bending, and present a simple model of active curvature that is able to produce many of the various sperm waveforms that are seen experimentally, including those in low and high viscosity fluids and after a cell has ‘hyperactivated’ (a chemical process thought to be key for fertilization). We will show comparisons between these simulated waveforms and sperm that have been experimentally tracked, and discuss methods for fitting simulated mechanistic parameters to these real cells.
Frustrated Self-Assembly of Non-Euclidean Crystals of Nanoparticles
Self-organized complex structures in nature, e.g., viral capsids, hierarchical biopolymers, and bacterial flagella, offer efficiency, adaptability, robustness, and multi-functionality. Can we program the self-assembly of three-dimensional (3D) complex structures using simple building blocks, and reach similar or higher level of sophistication in engineered materials? Here we present an analytic theory for the self-assembly of polyhedral nanoparticles (NPs) based on their crystal structures in non-Euclidean space. We show that the unavoidable geometrical frustration of these particle shapes, combined with competing attractive and repulsive interparticle interactions, lead to controllable self-assembly of structures of complex order. Applying this theory to tetrahedral NPs, we find high-yield and enantiopure self-assembly of helicoidal ribbons, exhibiting qualitative agreement with experimental observations. We expect that this theory will offer a general framework for the self-assembly of simple polyhedral building blocks into rich complex morphologies with new material capabilities such as tunable optical activity, essential for multiple emerging technologies.
Tissue fluidization at the onset of zebrafish gastrulation
Embryo morphogenesis is impacted by dynamic changes in tissue material properties, which have been proposed to occur via processes akin phase transitions (PTs). Here, we show that rigidity percolation provides a simple and robust theoretical framework to predict material/structural PTs of embryonic tissues from local cell connectivity. By using percolation theory, combined with directly monitoring dynamic changes in tissue rheology and cell contact mechanics, we demonstrate that the zebrafish blastoderm undergoes a genuine rigidity PT, brought about by a small reduction in adhesion-dependent cell connectivity below a critical value. We quantitatively predict and experimentally verify hallmarks of PTs, including power-law exponents and associated discontinuities of macroscopic observables at criticality. Finally, we show that this uniform PT depends on blastoderm cells undergoing meta-synchronous divisions causing random and, consequently, uniform changes in cell connectivity. Collectively, our theoretical and experimental findings reveal the structural basis of material PTs in an organismal context.
Magic numbers in protein phase transitions
Biologists have recently come to appreciate that eukaryotic cells are home to a multiplicity of non-membrane bound compartments, many of which form and dissolve as needed for the cell to function. These dynamical “condensates” enable many central cellular functions – from ribosome assembly, to RNA regulation and storage, to signaling and metabolism. While it is clear that these compartments represent a type of separated phase, what controls their formation, how specific biological components are included or excluded, and how these structures influence physiological and biochemical processes remain largely mysterious. I will discuss recent experiments on phase separated condensates both in vitro and in vivo, and will present theoretical results that highlight a novel “magic number” effect relevant to the formation and control of two-component phase separated condensates.
Mixed active-passive suspensions: from particle entrainment to spontaneous demixing
Understanding the properties of active matter is a challenge which is currently driving a rapid growth in soft- and bio-physics. Some of the most important examples of active matter are at the microscale, and include active colloids and suspensions of microorganisms, both as a simple active fluid (single species) and as mixed suspensions of active and passive elements. In this last class of systems, recent experimental and theoretical work has started to provide a window into new phenomena including activity-induced depletion interactions, phase separation, and the possibility to extract net work from active suspensions. Here I will present our work on a paradigmatic example of mixed active-passive system, where the activity is provided by swimming microalgae. Macro- and micro-scopic experiments reveal that microorganism-colloid interactions are dominated by rare close encounters leading to large displacements through direct entrainment. Simulations and theoretical modelling show that the ensuing particle dynamics can be understood in terms of a simple jump-diffusion process, combining standard diffusion with Poisson-distributed jumps. Entrainment length can be understood within the framework of Taylor dispersion as a competition between advection by the no-slip surface of the cell body and microparticle diffusion. Building on these results, we then ask how external control of the dynamics of the active component (e.g. induced microswimmer anisotropy/inhomogeneity) can be used to alter the transport of passive cargo. As a first step in this direction, we study the behaviour of mixed active-passive systems in confinement. The resulting spatial inhomogeneity in swimmers’ distribution and orientation has a dramatic effect on the spatial distribution of passive particles, with the colloids accumulating either towards the boundaries or towards the bulk of the sample depending on the size of the container. We show that this can be used to induce the system to de-mix spontaneously.
Non-equilibrium molecular assembly in reshaping and cutting cells
A key challenge in modern soft matter is to identify the principles that govern the organisation and functionality in non-equilibrium systems. Current research efforts largely focus on non-equilibrium processes that occur either at the single-molecule scale (e.g. protein and DNA conformations under driving forces), or at the scale of whole tissues, organisms, and active colloidal and microscopic objects. However, the range of the scales in-between — from molecules to large-scaled molecular assemblies that consume energy and perform work — remains under-explored. This is, nevertheless, the scale that is crucial for the function of a living cell, where molecular self-assembly driven far from equilibrium produces mechanical work needed for cell reshaping, transport, motility, division, and healing. Today I will discuss physical modelling of active elastic filaments, called ESCRT-III filaments, that dynamically assemble and disassemble on cell membranes. This dynamic assembly changes the filaments’ shape and mechanical properties and leads to the remodelling and cutting of cells. I will present a range of experimental comparisons of our simulation results: from ESCRT-III-driven trafficking in eukaryotes to division of evolutionary simple archaeal cells.
Imposed flow in active liquid crystals
Inspired by ongoing experiments on three dimensional active gels composed of sliding microtubule bundles, we study a few idealized problems in a minimal hydrodynamic model for active liquid crystals. Our aim is to use flow to determine the value of the coefficient of activity in a continuum theory. We consider the case of apolar active particles that form a disordered phase in the absence of flow, and study how activity affects the swimming speed of a prescribed swimmer, as well as the stability of a fluid interface. We also consider flows of active matter in channels or past immersed objects.
Stochastic control of passive colloidal objects by micro-swimmers
The way single colloidal objects behave in presence of active forces arising from within the bulk of the system is crucial to many situations, notably biological and ecological (e.g. intra-cellular transport, predation), and potential medical or environmental applications (e.g. targeted delivery of cargoes, depollution of waters and soils). In this talk I will present experimental findings that my collaborators and I have obtained over the past years on the dynamics of single Brownian colloids in suspensions of biological micro-swimmers, especially the green alga Chlamydomonas reinhardtii. I'll show notably that spatial heterogeneities and anisotropies in the active particles statistics can control the preferential localisation of their passive counterparts. The results will be rationalized using theoretical approaches from hydrodynamics and stochastic processes.
Neural network-like collective dynamics in molecules
Neural networks can learn and recognize subtle correlations in high dimensional inputs. However, neural networks are simply many-body systems with strong non-linearities and disordered interactions. Hence, many-body physical systems with similar interactions should be able to show neural network-like behavior. Here we show neural network-like behavior in the nucleation dynamics of promiscuously interacting molecules with multiple stable crystalline phases. Using a combination of theory and experiments, we show how the physics of the system dictates relationships between the difficulty of the pattern recognition task solved, time taken and accuracy. This work shows that high dimensional pattern recognition and learning are not special to software algorithms but can be achieved by the collective dynamics of sufficiently disordered molecular systems.
Is there universality in biology?
It is sometimes said that there are two reasons why physics is so successful as a science. One is that it deals with very simple problems. The other is that it attempts to account only for universal aspects of systems at a desired level of description, with lower level phenomena subsumed into a small number of adjustable parameters. It is a widespread belief that this approach seems unlikely to be useful in biology, which is intimidatingly complex, where “everything has an exception”, and where there are a huge number of undetermined parameters. I will try to argue, nonetheless, that there are important, experimentally-testable aspects of biology that exhibit universality, and should be amenable to being tackled from a physics perspective. My suggestion is that this can lead to useful new insights into the existence and universal characteristics of living systems. I will try to justify this point of view by contrasting the goals and practices of the field of condensed matter physics with materials science, and then by extension, the goals and practices of the newly emerging field of “Physics of Living Systems” with biology. Specific biological examples that I will discuss include the following: Universal patterns of gene expression in cell biology Universal scaling laws in ecosystems, including the species-area law, Kleiber’s law, Paradox of the Plankton Universality of the genetic code Universality of thermodynamic utilization in microbial communities Universal scaling laws in the tree of life The question of what can be learned from studying universal phenomena in biology will also be discussed. Universal phenomena, by their very nature, shed little light on detailed microscopic levels of description. Yet there is no point in seeking idiosyncratic mechanistic explanations for phenomena whose explanation is found in rather general principles, such as the central limit theorem, that every microscopic mechanism is constrained to obey. Thus, physical perspectives may be better suited to answering certain questions such as universality than traditional biological perspectives. Concomitantly, it must be recognized that the identification and understanding of universal phenomena may not be a good answer to questions that have traditionally occupied biological scientists. Lastly, I plan to talk about what is perhaps the central question of universality in biology: why does the phenomenon of life occur at all? Is it an inevitable consequence of the laws of physics or some special geochemical accident? What methodology could even begin to answer this question? I will try to explain why traditional approaches to biology do not aim to answer this question, by comparing with our understanding of superconductivity as a physical phenomenon, and with the theory of universal computation. References Nigel Goldenfeld, Tommaso Biancalani, Farshid Jafarpour. Universal biology and the statistical mechanics of early life. Phil. Trans. R. Soc. A 375, 20160341 (14 pages) (2017). Nigel Goldenfeld and Carl R. Woese. Life is Physics: evolution as a collective phenomenon far from equilibrium. Ann. Rev. Cond. Matt. Phys. 2, 375-399 (2011).
Building a synthetic cell: Understanding the clock design and function
Clock networks containing the same central architectures may vary drastically in their potential to oscillate, raising the question of what controls robustness, one of the essential functions of an oscillator. We computationally generate an atlas of oscillators and found that, while core topologies are critical for oscillations, local structures substantially modulate the degree of robustness. Strikingly, two local structures, incoherent and coherent inputs, can modify a core topology to promote and attenuate its robustness, additively. The findings underscore the importance of local modifications to the performance of the whole network. It may explain why auxiliary structures not required for oscillations are evolutionary conserved. We also extend this computational framework to search hidden network motifs for other clock functions, such as tunability that relates to the capabilities of a clock to adjust timing to external cues. Experimentally, we developed an artificial cell system in water-in-oil microemulsions, within which we reconstitute mitotic cell cycles that can perform self-sustained oscillations for 30 to 40 cycles over multiple days. The oscillation profiles, such as period, amplitude, and shape, can be quantitatively varied with the concentrations of clock regulators, energy levels, droplet sizes, and circuit design. Such innate flexibility makes it crucial to studying clock functions of tunability and stochasticity at the single-cell level. Combined with a pressure-driven multi-channel tuning setup and long-term time-lapse fluorescence microscopy, this system enables a high-throughput exploration in multi-dimension continuous parameter space and single-cell analysis of the clock dynamics and functions. We integrate this experimental platform with mathematical modeling to elucidate the topology-function relation of biological clocks. With FRET and optogenetics, we also investigate spatiotemporal cell-cycle dynamics in both homogeneous and heterogeneous microenvironments by reconstructing subcellular compartments.
“Models for Liquid-liquid Phase Separation of Intrinsically Disordered Proteins”
Intrinsically disordered proteins (IDPs), lack of a well-defined folded structure, have been recently shown to be critical to forming membrane-less organelles via liquid-liquid phase separation (LLPS). Due to the flexible conformations of IDPs, it could be challenging to investigate IDPs with solely experimental techniques. Computational models can therefore provide complementary views at several aspects, including the fundamental physics underlying LLPS and the sequence determinants contributing to LLPS. In this presentation, I will start with our coarse-grained computational framework that can help generate sequence dependent phase diagrams. The coarse-grained model further led to the development of a polymer model with empirical parameters to quickly predict LLPS of IDPs. At last, I will show our preliminary efforts on addressing molecular interactions within LLPS of IDPs using all-atom explicit-solvent simulations.
Motility control in biological microswimmers
It is often assumed that biological swimmers conform faithfully to certain stereotypes assigned to them by physicists and mathematicians, when the reality is in fact much more complicated. In this talk we will use a combination of theory, experiments, and robotics, to understand the physical and evolutionary basis of motility control in a number of distinguished organisms. These organisms differ markedly in terms of their size, shape, and arrangement of locomotor appendages, but are united in their use of cilia - the ultimate shape-shifting organelle - to achieve self-propulsion and navigation.
Adhering, wrapping, and bursting of lipid bilayer membranes: understanding effects of membrane-binding particles and polymers
Proteins and membranes form remarkably complex structures that are key to intracellular compartmentalization, cargo transport, and cell morphology. Despite this wealth of examples in living systems, we still lack design principles for controlling membrane morphology in synthetic systems. With experiments and simulations, we show that even the simple case of spherical or rod-shaped nanoparticles binding to lipid-bilayer membrane vesicles results in a remarkably rich set of morphologies that can be reliably controlled via the particle binding energy. When the binding energy is weak relative to a characteristic membrane-bending energy, vesicles adhere to one another and form a soft solid gel, which is a useful platform for controlled release. With larger binding energy, a transition from partial to complete wrapping of the nanoparticles causes a remarkable vesicle destruction process culminating in rupture, nanoparticle-membrane tubules, and vesicle inversion. We have explored the behavior across a wide range of parameter space. These findings help unify the wide range of effects observed when vesicles or cells are exposed to nanoparticles. They also show how they open the door to a new class of vesicle-based, closed-cell gels that are more than 99% water and can encapsulate and release on demand. I will discuss how triggering membrane remodeling could lead to shape-responsive systems in the future.
Biology is “messy”. So how can we take theory in biology seriously and plot predictions and experiments on the same axes?
Many of us came to biology from physics. There we have been trained on such classic examples as muon g-2, where experimental data and theoretical predictions agree to many significant digits. Now, working in biology, we routinely hear that it is messy, most details matter, and that the best hope for theory in biology is to be semi-qualitative, predict general trends, and to forgo the hope of ever making quantitative predictions with the precision that we are used to in physics. Colloquially, we should be satisfied even if data and models differ so much that plotting them on the same plot makes little sense. However, some of us won’t be satisfied by this. So can we take theory in biology seriously and predict experimental outcomes within (small) error bars? Certainly, we won’t be able to predict everything, but this is never required, even in traditional physics. But we should be able to choose some features of data that are nontrivial and interesting, and focus on them. We also should be able to find different classes of models --- maybe even null models --- that match biology better, and thus allow for a better agreement. It is even possible that large-dimensional datasets of modern high-throughput experiments, and the ensuing “more is different” statistical physics style models will make quantitative, precise theory easier. To explore the role of quantitative theory in biology, in this workshop, eight speakers will address some of the following general questions based on their specific work in different corners of biology: Which features of biological data are predictable? Which types of models are best suited to making quantitative predictions in different fields? Should theorists interested in quantitative predictions focus on different questions, not typically asked by biologists? Do large, multidimensional datasets make theories (and which theories?) more or less likely to succeed? This will be an unapologetically theoretical physics workshop — we won’t focus on a specific subfield of biology, but will explore these questions across the fields, hoping that the underlying theoretical frameworks will help us find the missing connections.
Spontaneous and driven active matter flows
Understanding individual and macroscopic transport properties of motile micro-organisms in complex environments is a timely question, relevant to many ecological, medical and technological situations. At the fundamental level, this question is also receiving a lot of attention as fluids loaded with swimming micro-organisms has become a rich domain of applications and a conceptual playground for the statistical physics of “active matter”. The existence of microscopic sources of energy borne by the motile character of these micro-swimmers is driving self-organization processes at the origin of original emergent phases and unconventional macroscopic properties leading to revisit many standard concepts in the physics of suspensions. In this presentation, I will report on a recent exploration on the question of spontaneous formation of large scale collective motion in relation with the rheological response of active suspensions. I will also present new experiments showing how the motility of bacteria can be controlled such as to extract work macroscopically.
“Cell Surface Topography: The Role of Protein Size at Cell-Cell Interfaces”
Membrane interfaces formed at junctions between cells are often associated with characteristic patterns of membrane protein organization, such as in epithelial tissues and between cells of the immune system. While this organization can be influenced by receptor clustering, lipid domain formation, and cytoskeletal dynamics, this talk will describe how cell surface molecular height can directly contribute to the spatial arrangement of membrane proteins and downstream signaling. Using a new optical method for characterizing molecular height, together with experiments using giant vesicles in vitro systems and live immune cells, we are investigating how cell surface molecular heights can be key contributors to cell-cell communication.
Flow, fluctuate and freeze: Epithelial cell sheets as soft active matter
Epithelial cell sheets form a fundamental role in the developing embryo, and also in adult tissues including the gut and the cornea of the eye. Soft and active matter provides a theoretical and computational framework to understand the mechanics and dynamics of these tissues.I will start by introducing the simplest useful class of models, active brownian particles (ABPs), which incorporate uncoordinated active crawling over a substrate and mechanical interactions. Using this model, I will show how the extended ’swirly’ velocity fluctuations seen in sheets on a substrate can be understood using a simple model that couples linear elasticity with disordered activity. We are able to quantitatively match experiments using in-vitro corneal epithelial cells.Adding a different source of activity, cell division and apoptosis, to such a model leads to a novel 'self-melting' dense fluid state. Finally, I will discuss a direct application of this simple particle-based model to the steady-state spiral flow pattern on the mouse cornea.
Length Scales and Dynamics in Contractile Active Gels
Most materials deform when external stresses are applied. This paradigm is familiar to sculptors who deform clay to produce structures. However, living materials such as cells and embryos are capable of deforming on their own. Contractile active gels of the proteins actin and myosin are one of the main drivers of force generation in biology. Here I will present experiments that characterize the length-scale behavior of active gel contraction, which find evidence for critical behavior. I will then present experiments that characterize the dynamics of active gel contraction, which identify dynamic precursors to contraction.
Swimming in the third domain: archaeal extremophiles
Archaea have evolved to survive in some of the most extreme environments on earth. Life in extreme, nutrient-poor conditions gives the opportunity to probe fundamental energy limitations on movement and response to stimuli, two essential markers of living systems. Here we use three-dimensional holographic microscopy and computer simulations to show that halophilic archaea achieve chemotaxis with power requirements one hundred-fold lower than common eubacterial model systems. Their swimming direction is stabilised by their flagella (archaella), enhancing directional persistence in a manner similar to that displayed by eubacteria, albeit with a different motility apparatus. Our experiments and simulations reveal that the cells are capable of slow but deterministic chemotaxis up a chemical gradient, in a biased random walk at the thermodynamic limit.
(What) can soft matter physics teach us about biological function?
The “soft, active, and living matter” community has grown tremendously in recent years, conducting exciting research at the interface between soft matter and biological systems. But are all living systems also soft matter systems? Do the ideas of function (or purpose) in biological systems require us to introduce deep new ideas into the framework of soft matter theories? Does the (often) qualitatively different character of data in biological experiments require us to change the types of experiments we conduct and the goals of our theoretical treatments? Eight speakers will anchor the workshop, exploring these questions across a range of biological system scales. Each speaker will deliver a 10-minute talk with another 10 minutes set aside for moderated questions/discussion. We expect the talks to be broad, bold, and provocative, discussing both the nature of the theoretical tools and experimental techniques we have at present and also those we think we will ultimately need to answer deep questions at the interface of soft matter and biology.
Dynamics of microbiota communities during physical perturbation
The consortium of microbes living in and on our bodies is intimately connected with human biology and deeply influenced by physical forces. Despite incredible gains in describing this community, and emerging knowledge of the mechanisms linking it to human health, understanding the basic physical properties and responses of this ecosystem has been comparatively neglected. Most diseases have significant physical effects on the gut; diarrhea alters osmolality, fever and cancer increase temperature, and bowel diseases affect pH. Furthermore, the gut itself is comprised of localized niches that differ significantly in their physical environment, and are inhabited by different commensal microbes. Understanding the impact of common physical factors is necessary for engineering robust microbiota members and communities; however, our knowledge of how they affect the gut ecosystem is poor. We are investigating how changes in osmolality affect the host and the microbial community and lead to mechanical shifts in the cellular environment. Osmotic perturbation is extremely prevalent in humans, caused by the use of laxatives, lactose intolerance, or celiac disease. In our studies we monitored osmotic shock to the microbiota using a comprehensive and novel approach, which combined in vivo experiments to imaging, physical measurements, computational analysis and highly controlled microfluidic experiments. By bridging several disciplines, we developed a mechanistic understanding of the processes involved in osmotic diarrhea, linking single-cell biophysical changes to large-scale community dynamics. Our results indicate that physical perturbations can profoundly and permanently change the competitive and ecological landscape of the gut, and affect the cell wall of bacteria differentially, depending on their mechanical characteristics.
Can machine learning learn new physics, or do we need to put it in by hand?"\
There has been a surge of publications on using machine learning (ML) on experimental data from physical systems: social, biological, statistical, and quantum. However, can these methods discover fundamentally new physics? It can be that their biggest impact is in better data preprocessing, while inferring new physics is unrealistic without specifically adapting the learning machine to find what we are looking for — that is, without the “intuition” — and hence without having a good a priori guess about what we will find. Is machine learning a useful tool for physics discovery? Which minimal knowledge should we endow the machines with to make them useful in such tasks? How do we do this? Eight speakers below will anchor the workshop, exploring these questions in contexts of diverse systems (from quantum to biological), and from general theoretical advances to specific applications. Each speaker will deliver a 10 min talk with another 10 minutes set aside for moderated questions/discussion. We expect the talks to be broad, bold, and provocative, discussing where the field is heading, and what is needed to get us there.
Physics of Behavior: Now that we can track (most) everything, what can we do with the data?
We will organize the workshop around one question: “Now that we can track (most) everything, what can we do with the data?” Given the recent dramatic advances in technology, we now have behavioral data sets with orders of magnitude more accuracy, dimensionality, diversity, and size than we had even a few years ago. That being said, there is still little agreement as to what theoretical frameworks can inform our understanding of these data sets and suggest new experiments we can perform. We hope that after this workshop we’ll see a variety of new ideas and perhaps gain some inspiration. We have invited eight speakers, each studying different systems, scales, and topics, to provide 10 minute presentations focused on the above question, with another 10 minutes set aside for questions/discussions (moderated by the two of us). Although we naturally expect speakers to include aspects of their own work, we have encouraged all of them to think broadly and provocatively. We are also hoping to organize some breakout sessions after the talks so that we can have some more expanded discussions about topics arising during the meeting.
experiment coverage
41 items