A perturbative approach to understand retinal computations
A major challenge in sensory systems is to understand how neurons extract information from the natural environment. Models derived from their responses to artificial stimuli often have a hard time to generalize and predict responses to natural scenes. However, models directly learned on the responses to natural scenes can be hard to interpret. To address this issue, we have recently developed an approach where we add small perturbations to natural scenes and measure how these perturbations change neuronal responses, to better understand the features extracted by sensory neurons. I will show several applications of this approach in the retina, and how it allowed us to uncover non-linear computations performed by ganglion cells, the retinal output. Presented in the van Vreeswijk Theoretical Neuroscience Seminar series (formerly WWTNS) on 2025-03-12. Recording duration: 00:47:06.
Neural circuits for vision in the natural world
Context-dependent selectivity to natural scenes in the retina
Synthetic and natural images unlock the power of recurrency in primary visual cortex
During perception the visual system integrates current sensory evidence with previously acquired knowledge of the visual world. Presumably this computation relies on internal recurrent interactions. We record populations of neurons from the primary visual cortex of cats and macaque monkeys and find evidence for adaptive internal responses to structured stimulation that change on both slow and fast timescales. In the first experiment, we present abstract images, only briefly, a protocol known to produce strong and persistent recurrent responses in the primary visual cortex. We show that repetitive presentations of a large randomized set of images leads to enhanced stimulus encoding on a timescale of minutes to hours. The enhanced encoding preserves the representational details required for image reconstruction and can be detected in post-exposure spontaneous activity. In a second experiment, we show that the encoding of natural scenes across populations of V1 neurons is improved, over a timescale of hundreds of milliseconds, with the allocation of spatial attention. Given the hierarchical organization of the visual cortex, contextual information from the higher levels of the processing hierarchy, reflecting high-level image regularities, can inform the activity in V1 through feedback. We hypothesize that these fast attentional boosts in stimulus encoding rely on recurrent computations that capitalize on the presence of high-level visual features in natural scenes. We design control images dominated by low-level features and show that, in agreement with our hypothesis, the attentional benefits in stimulus encoding vanish. We conclude that, in the visual system, powerful recurrent processes optimize neuronal responses, already at the earliest stages of cortical processing.
Retinal responses to natural inputs
The research in my lab focuses on sensory signal processing, particularly in cases where sensory systems perform at or near the limits imposed by physics. Photon counting in the visual system is a beautiful example. At its peak sensitivity, the performance of the visual system is limited largely by the division of light into discrete photons. This observation has several implications for phototransduction and signal processing in the retina: rod photoreceptors must transduce single photon absorptions with high fidelity, single photon signals in photoreceptors, which are only 0.03 – 0.1 mV, must be reliably transmitted to second-order cells in the retina, and absorption of a single photon by a single rod must produce a noticeable change in the pattern of action potentials sent from the eye to the brain. My approach is to combine quantitative physiological experiments and theory to understand photon counting in terms of basic biophysical mechanisms. Fortunately there is more to visual perception than counting photons. The visual system is very adept at operating over a wide range of light intensities (about 12 orders of magnitude). Over most of this range, vision is mediated by cone photoreceptors. Thus adaptation is paramount to cone vision. Again one would like to understand quantitatively how the biophysical mechanisms involved in phototransduction, synaptic transmission, and neural coding contribute to adaptation.
A Panoramic View on Vision
Statistics of natural scenes are not uniform - their structure varies dramatically from ground to sky. It remains unknown whether these non-uniformities are reflected in the large-scale organization of the early visual system and what benefits such adaptations would confer. By deploying an efficient coding argument, we predict that changes in the structure of receptive fields across visual space increase the efficiency of sensory coding. To test this experimentally, developed a simple, novel imaging system that is indispensable for studies at this scale. In agreement with our predictions, we could show that receptive fields of retinal ganglion cells change their shape along the dorsoventral axis, with a marked surround asymmetry at the visual horizon. Our work demonstrates that, according to principles of efficient coding, the panoramic structure of natural scenes is exploited by the retina across space and cell-types.
Target detection in the natural world
Animal sensory systems are optimally adapted to those features typically encountered in natural surrounds, thus allowing neurons that have a limited bandwidth to encode almost impossibly large input ranges. Importantly, natural scenes are not random, and peripheral visual systems have therefore evolved to reduce the predictable redundancy. The vertebrate visual cortex is also optimally tuned to the spatial statistics of natural scenes, but much less is known about how the insect brain responds to these. We are redressing this deficiency using several techniques. Olga Dyakova uses exquisite image manipulation to give natural images unnatural image statistics, or vice versa. Marissa Holden then uses these images as stimuli in electrophysiological recordings of neurons in the fly optic lobes, to see how the brain codes for the statistics typically encountered in natural scenes, and Olga Dyakova measures the behavioral optomotor response on our trackball set-up.
What the eye tells the brain: Visual feature extraction in the mouse retina
Visual processing begins in the retina: within only two synaptic layers, multiple parallel feature channels emerge, which relay highly processed visual information to different parts of the brain. To functionally characterize these feature channels we perform calcium and glutamate population activity recordings at different levels of the mouse retina. This allows following the complete visual signal across consecutive processing stages in a systematic way. In my talk, I will summarize our recent findings on the functional diversity of retinal output channels and how they arise within the retinal network. Specifically, I will talk about the role of inhibition and cell-type specific dendritic processing in generating diverse visual channels. Then, I will focus on how color – a single visual feature – emerges across all retinal processing layers and link our results to behavioral output and the statistics of mouse natural scenes. With our approach, we hope to identify general computational principles of retinal signaling, thereby increasing our understanding of what the eye tells the brain.
Toward a High-fidelity Artificial Retina for Vision Restoration
Electronic interfaces to the retina represent an exciting development in science, engineering, and medicine – an opportunity to exploit our knowledge of neural circuitry and function to restore or even enhance vision. However, although existing devices demonstrate proof of principle in treating incurable blindness, they produce limited visual function. Some of the reasons for this can be understood based on the precise and specific neural circuitry that mediates visual signaling in the retina. Consideration of this circuitry suggests that future devices may need to operate at single-cell, single-spike resolution in order to mediate naturalistic visual function. I will show large-scale multi-electrode recording and stimulation data from the primate retina indicating that, in some cases, such resolution is possible. I will also discuss cases in which it fails, and propose that we can improve artificial vision in such conditions by incorporating our knowledge of the visual system in bi-directional devices that adapt to the host neural circuitry. Finally, I will introduce the Stanford Artificial Retina Project, aimed at developing a retinal implant that more faithfully reproduces the neural code of the retina, and briefly discuss the implications for scientific investigation and for other neural interfaces of the future.
Human reconstruction of local image structure from natural scenes
Retinal projections often poorly represent the structure of the physical world: well-defined boundaries within the eye may correspond to irrelevant features of the physical world, while critical features of the physical world may be nearly invisible at the retinal projection. Visual cortex is equipped with specialized mechanisms for sorting these two types of features according to their utility in interpreting the scene, however we know little or nothing about their perceptual computations. I will present novel paradigms for the characterization of these processes in human vision, alongside examples of how the associated empirical results can be combined with targeted models to shape our understanding of the underlying perceptual mechanisms. Although the emerging view is far from complete, it challenges compartmentalized notions of bottom-up/top-down object segmentation, and suggests instead that these two modes are best viewed as an integrated perceptual mechanism.